Sign up to the Independent's betting newsletter for the latest tips and offers Sign up to the Independent's betting newsletter
England will never get that World Cup semi-final back . Nothing they do in Rijeka tomorrow night can redress any balance, or make any amends for what happened on 11 July. All they can do is try to avoid the same mistakes.
Three months on from the Luzhniki, distance and perspective does nothing to diminish the historical importance of the night. Like a mountain that only looks bigger as you start to drive away from it. For those players and for Gareth Southgate – even after he signed his new contract – it is unlikely that they will ever play in a game that big again.
That sense of history and permanence is why that defeat felt like more than a defeat. It felt like a judgement. And that is why we are all still agonising about it now, and about what went wrong and why England lost.
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratingsShow all 22 1 /22Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings <b>Croatia:</b> Danijel Subasic – 6 out of 10 His position for the opening goal was questionable and his dive wasn’t all that either. Possibly still feeling the effects of his hamstring niggle suffered in the quarter-final.
AFP/Getty Images
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Sime Vrsaljko – 8 out of 10 An injury doubt heading into the game that will have been relieved to see Raheem Sterling targeting the left side of the Croatian defence. Pushed forward as England went into their shells, and it was his superb cross that allowed Perisic to volley home and level the scores.
AFP/Getty Images
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Dejan Lovren – 5 out of 10 On thin ice early with referee Cuneyt Cakir and somehow stayed out of the referee’s book. Ran ragged throughout the first half by Sterling and Lingard, and looked like a walking red card waiting to happen. But as England’s attack faded away, the pressure on him eased.
AP
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Domagoj Vida – 7 out of 10 The more commanding of the two Croatian centre-backs, though that isn’t saying much in comparison to Lovren’s performance.
AFP/Getty Images
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Ivan Strinic – 5 out of 10 Found himself under a heap of pressure as Sterling and Trippier double-teamed him, putting him in a spin that England were unable to take full advantage of.
AP
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Marcelo Brozovic – 6 out of 10 It was his loss of concentration that allowed Dele Alli to slip by and force Luka Modric into the foul that led to the opening goal. Looked more assured thereafter, and was one of the main reasons why Croatia were able to turn the tables.
EPA
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Ante Rebic – 6 out of 10 Must have been one of the most frustrated players on the pitch as he saw no fewer than three shots blocked by the stubborn England defence, before being replaced by Anrej Kramaric.
AP
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Luka Modric – 6 out of 10 Exposed defensively as Dele Alli drew the early foul that set-up England’s opener and looked very much like a 31-year-old who has been dragged through three lung-busting extra-time matches. A shadow of the player we’re used to seeing.
EPA
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Ivan Rakitic – 6 out of 10 Just as disappointing as Modric and for all the high billing that the Liga duo were given, they flattered to deceive.
AP
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Ivan Perisic – 9 out of 10 Wasted possession early on when Croatia were trailing as he wastefully shot from distance, but made his impact on the game – and then some. He made a lovely run to get in front of Kyle Walker to score Croatia’s deserved equaliser, and it was his determination that got him to the ball first to head into the path of Mandzukic to score the winner.
EPA
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Wasted possession early on when Croatia were trailing as he wastefully shot from distance, but made his impact on the game – and then some. He made a lovely run to get in front of Kyle Walker to score Croatia’s deserved equaliser, and it was his determina Took a clattering from Pickford when the two collided in close-range to the England goal, but brushed it off to score the crucial goal that sent Croatia through to the World Cup final.
AP
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings <England:</b> Jordan Pickford – 6 out of 10 Involved in a nasty-looking collision with Rebic early on but brushed himself down and looked composed as ever. Didn’t have too many saves to make as England’s defence made block after block, but the resilience finally broke.
Getty Images
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Kyle Walker – 6 out of 10 Bailed England out with his phenomenal pace on numerous occasions as Croatia pushed on in the second half in search of the goal they needed, but just like the opening game against Tunisia he was exposed aerially for Perisic’s equaliser.
AFP/Getty Images
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings John Stones – 7 out of 10 England’s most impressive defender as he put his body on the line and looked to block anything that came down the centre channel. A strong performance that was undone by his hesitation that allowed Mandzukic in behind to score the winner.
AFP/Getty Images
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Harry Maguire – 6 out of 10 Tried to impose at England’s set-pieces but to no avail.
Getty Images
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Kieran Trippier – 8 out of 10 Lovely free-kick to open the scoring in the fifth minute dared England to dream and was reward for his efforts at the tournament. The sight of him being carried off injured as extra-time ticked down was a sad one.
AP
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Jordan Henderson – 6 out of 10 Made little impression on the match as Croatia were able to bypass the England midfield with relative ease.
EPA
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Dele Alli – 6 out of 10 Won the free-kick that produced Trippier’s goal, but that’s just about all he managed and he lost possession too often as England allowed the game to slip away.
AFP/Getty Images
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Ashley Young – 6 out of 10 Crucial touch to nip the ball away from Perisic just as he cocked his right leg to shoot at goal early on.
EPA
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Jesse Lingard – 6 out of 10 For someone who is capable of the beautiful goal he scored against Panama, he goes missing in games too often. Croatia were able to withstand his early onslaught with Sterling and after that he pretty much disappeared from view.
AP
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Raheem Sterling – 6 out of 10 Another who disappointed in terms of the final product. Made a number of runs early on that made him look the most dangerous player out there, but too often he was either on his own or ran into a dead end and was replaced by Marcus Rashford when England started to chase the game.
EPA
Croatia vs England World Cup player ratings Harry Kane – 5 out of 10 Missed two chances in front of goal that he would have expected to score in his sleep – not knowing that he had been flagged offside both times. Looked completely spent come the end of normal time as he slipped back into midfield once again, and you would not be surprised if he has been carrying an injury since the Colombia game.
AFP/Getty Images
It has not been easy, especially for those players who were just over 20 minutes away from the immortality that a place in the final would have brought. Speaking at St George’s Park ahead of last month’s games, Harry Maguire admitted that he still found it “tough” to watch the game back in full, because of how close England had got.
But it is Southgate’s job to pore over the footage with his staff and try to get to the bottom of what had gone wrong. How did a 1-0 lead, pregnant with the promise of swarmed airport returns, national holidays, open-top bus parades, knighthoods, and lives transformed for ever, turn into a 2-1 defeat in little over half an hour?
Southgate’s initial diagnosis, speaking in St Petersburg before the third-placed play-off, was that England had given the ball away too easily in the second half. The first five games of building the ball out from the back in Russia had been thrown out of the window when it mattered most. “We could have been a bit braver in our support positions,” he said. “We went longer and turned the ball over a bit more, it allowed Croatia to have more possession.”
Anyone who saw the game will remember in that long stretched second half how willingly England gave the ball up to Croatia. And how England’s tiring legs sapped the energy from their attempts to press. Soon enough, every time Luka Modric and Ivan Rakitic got the ball, they had a split second more time on it. Gradually but inevitably, the tide had turned back against England.
England vs Croatia: Story of the gameShow all 190 1 /190England vs Croatia: Story of the game England vs Croatia: Story of the game England and Croatian fans pose in Red Square ahead of the match
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Fans in the stands before the semi-final
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Mario Mandzukic in action with John Stones
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kieran Trippier Goal
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Raheem Sterling battles for the ball
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kieran Trippier of England celebrates
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Jordan Pickford makes a save from Croatia's Ivan Perisic
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Kieran Trippier celebrates scoring
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kieran Trippier after the first goal of the game
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia goalkeeper Danijel Subasic dives
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Jordan Pickford celebrates
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Kieran Trippier celebrates scoring their first goal with Harry Kane
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Mario Mandzukic in action with John Stones
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England Celebrate
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Jordan Pickford in action with Croatia's Ante Rebic
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Up and over for Pickford
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Danijel Subasic of Croatia makes a save on Harry Kane of England
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia attempt to fight back
Tim Goode/PA Wire
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Pickford save
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kyle Walker goes for the head
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Jordan Pickford of England collides with Ante Rebic of Croatia
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Jordan Pickford takes a stroll
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Danijel Subasic of Croatia makes a save on Harry Kane of England
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Referee Cuneyt Cakir talks to Kyle Walker
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Ashley Young takes a throw
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kyle Walker and John Stones in action with Croatia's Domagoj Vida
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Raheem Sterling in action with Croatia's Ivan Rakitic
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia's Ivan Rakitic in action with England's Kyle Walker
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Jordan Pickford of England during the 2018 FIFA World Cup Russia Semi Final match between England and Croatia at Luzhniki Stadium
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia team group. Top Row (left to right) Dejan Lovren, Ivan Strinic, Mario Mandzukic, Ante Rebic, Danijel Subasic and Ivan Perisic. Bottom Row (left to right) Marcelo Brozovic, Domagoj Vida, Ivan Rakitic, Sime Vrsaljko and Luka Modric
Tim Goode/PA Wire
England vs Croatia: Story of the game General view inside the stadium
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Rakitic of Croatia confronts referee Cuneyt
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game hairman of the Football Association Greg Clarke, Prime Minister of Russia Dmitry Medvedev and FIFA president Gianni Infantino during the match
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Rakitic of Croatia and Luka Modric of Croatia confront referee Cuneyt Cakir
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Fans in Millennium Square, Leeds
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Zlatko Dalic, Head coach of Croatia looks on
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia's Luka Modric at half time
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Luka Modric concerned for Croatia
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Rakitic of Croatia confronts referee
Getty Images
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Television monitors inside the stadium
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Harry Kane in action
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Harry Kane in action with Ivan Strinic
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England fans in Moscow
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Harry Kane falls
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Dele Alli header
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate looks on
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Marcelo Brozovic heads it
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia fans in Zagreb
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Kyle Walker sit on the floor
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Sterling v Strinic
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kyle Walker of England lies on the pitch injured
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Harry Kane in action with Croatia's Marcelo Brozovic and Ivan Rakitic
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Harry Maguire and Croatia's Luka Modr
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Kieran Trippier and Croatia's Ivan Rakitic battle
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Dele Alli of England looks on
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Jordan Pickford of England kicks the ball away
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ashley Young of England looks on
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Sime Vrsaljko of Croatia challenges Raheem Sterling
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Jordan Pickford during the match
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Gareth Southgate leads
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia fans
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Strinic of Croatia is challenged by Kieran Trippier
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game ngland's Harry Kane in action with Croatia's Dejan Lovren
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England's Raheem Sterling in action with Croatia's Sime Vrsaljko
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Harry Kane of England lies on the pitch
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Modric in peril
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Vrsaljko with Sterling
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Pickford directs
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kyle Walker of England clashes with Ivan Perisic
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Throw in by Ashley Young
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Luka Modric of Croatia pleads
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane fights for the ball
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ref stops play
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Perisic goal
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane gets thirsty
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Perisic celebrates the equaliser
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Walker injury time
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Perisic gets round Pickford
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Right through Pickford
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Perisic gets Croatia's first
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Perisic celebrates his goal
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Perisic scores
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Strinic skills
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Crouching PIckford
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Perisic celebrates
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia hit the post
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Three lions roar from the stadium
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game It all falls down
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Catch by Pickford
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate enthusiasm
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate unsure
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Birdseye view
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane anxious
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Perisic of Croatia scores his team's first goal
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Vida slides along
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate contemplates the outcome
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Ivan Perisic of Croatia scores
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia celebrates a goal
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia at half-time
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate checks the clock
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate watches his team
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane looks on
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Pickford jumps for the ball
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Pickford holds out his arms
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane from behind
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia Manager
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia go for the ball
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate applauds the teams
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Extra time is upon us
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane battles
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Brozovic flies
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Brozovic and Kane battle
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Modric takes the ball
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Perisic in action
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Captain Modric takes command
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Pickford shouts it out
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Despair form the fans
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate considers his team
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Injury time
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Sub time
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Injury checks by the ref
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatian fans
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Danny Rose tackled
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Dier gets ready
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Dier gets steady
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Dier comes on
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Zlatko Dalic directs
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game FIFA President attends the matchDier
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Pickford in action
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Dalic fury
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Vrsaljko clears the ball off the line
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Stones heads the ball
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Dele Alli challenged
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia's second goal
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia takes the lead
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England huddle
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England desperate
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate team talk
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Crotia huddle
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Crotia Score
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Crotia celebrate
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Crotia in action
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate calls out
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England chance
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Trippier injury
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia 2 up
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England unsure
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Pickford dejected
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Vardy in despair
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatian joy
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia celebrate 2-1
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatian fan looking tense
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia celebrates going ahead
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England lose 2-1
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England abandon hope
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England loss
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Final whistle
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane is coming home
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game They think it's all over
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia win 2-1
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate consols
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England and Croatia managers pay their respects
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane upset
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Pickford gives up
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Kane dejected
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Rashford out
Getty
England vs Croatia: Story of the game England fall
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatian pride
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Southgate huddle
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia celebrate a 2-1 win
REUTERS
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Croatia celebrate
PA
England vs Croatia: Story of the game Going home, goodbye Moscow
REUTERS
After a long summer of reflection, Southgate came back to international duty saying that the rot had set in even earlier than he first thought. It was the end of the first half, when England were still 1-0 up and on top, that they had started to go against what Southgate had taught them. “Our biggest issue was not keeping the ball,” Southgate said. “We have to keep the ball better under pressure, and we stopped doing that. It seemed like it was the second half, but actually there were moments in the first half where we were the same. Because we were ahead, we went a bit safer.”
This has been Southgate’s central post-World Cup message to his team: being braver in positioning and passing when they have the ball. Although the evidence of the 2-1 defeat to Spain at Wembley, when England took the lead before being technically outclassed, showed how difficult that will be. Good intentions and accurate diagnoses will never be enough.
But then how could England improve much on the World Cup for that Spain game when they went in with the same midfield? With Jordan Henderson, Dele Alli and Jesse Lingard in midfield again there was little prospect of any improvement. That was a midfield trio built on energy and running, and when their energy ran out against Croatia, they had nothing left to contribute. Against Spain at Wembley it was not a very different story.
England vs Spain - player ratingsShow all 22 1 /22England vs Spain - player ratings England vs Spain - player ratings Jordan Pickford - 6 out of 10 Could do little about the two goals scored in the first half and wasn’t required to do much more after that.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs Spain - player ratings Joe Gomez - 5 Looked a little troubled to begin with but came into his own.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs Spain - player ratings John Stones - 6 Made a great tackle in the second half to stop Rodrigo breaking free but got booked for it, otherwise did a decent job in the centre of the defence.
REUTERS
England vs Spain - player ratings Harry Maguire - 6 Controlled at the back in possession even under pressure from the Spanish strikers.
Getty Images
England vs Spain - player ratings Jordan Henderson - 5 Got sucked away from the near post for Spain’s second goal which allowed Rodrigo to find the gap and score.
REUTERS
England vs Spain - player ratings Kieran Trippier - 6 Brought down Alonso in a needless diving challenge which led to the second Spanish goal, went forward well but didn’t deliver as well as we’d have liked.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs Spain - player ratings Jesse Lingard - 6 Lit the game up for England when he combined with Alli on the attack but saw too little of the ball and had to cover too much when defending.
Getty Images
England vs Spain - player ratings Dele Alli - 6 Couldn’t make a lasting impact due to England struggling to get the ball forward.
REUTERS
England vs Spain - player ratings Luke Shaw - 7 Had a great start to the game, setting up Rashford for the opener but gave Carvajal too much room in defence leading to the equaliser for Spain, he recovered after this mishap and performed well.
PA
England vs Spain - player ratings Marcus Rashford - 8 Scored the opener and could have had a second with a fiercer header in the first half.
REUTERS
England vs Spain - player ratings Harry Kane - 6 Sent Rashford through on goal in the second half and he held the ball up and turned well but he didn’t see enough of it to make a proper impact. Spain
AP
England vs Spain - player ratings David De Gea - 7 out of 10 Made a fantastic save to deny Rashford equalising and keep Spain in front.
REUTERS
England vs Spain - player ratings Dani Carvajal - 8 Was great all night, he put pressure on Shaw and Maguire down the left and tracked back superbly.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs Spain - player ratings Nacho Fernandez - 6 Steadfast in defence following England’s first, barely gave England a chance.
Getty Images
England vs Spain - player ratings Sergio Ramos - 6 Got booed by the English fans but delivered quality long balls and looked confident in defence.
AP
England vs Spain - player ratings Marcos Alonso - 6 Was strong in mid-field and won a few free kicks for Spain in dangerous areas including the one which led to their second goal.
Getty
England vs Spain - player ratings Thiago Alcantara - 7 Whipped in the low cross from out wide, finding Rodrigo with perfection.
EPA
England vs Spain - player ratings Sergio Busquets - 7 Did what he does, commanded the mid-field playing through he wide men and creating space with ease.
REUTERS
England vs Spain - player ratings Saul Niguez - 8 Scored the equaliser for Spain with a solid shot in a tricky situation, perfectly placing the ball past Pickford.
AP
England vs Spain - player ratings Rodrigo Moreno - 9 Played a perfect pass into Saul to get the equaliser for Spain before putting them in front after meeting Thiago’s free kick. The best player on the pitch.
AP
England vs Spain - player ratings Iago Aspas - 6 Linked very well with Rodrigo up front and wasn’t afraid to take the challenge to England and shoot from anywhere on the pitch.
REUTERS
England vs Spain - player ratings Isco - 6 Had free roam on the pitch and made use of it, he ran through the centre, down the left, over on the right basically he was everywhere a nightmare to defend against.
AFP/Getty Images
Had Southgate taken the same players to Croatia this week then we may be facing the prospect of another repeat. Of the lessons of the Luzhniki still going unlearned, of English energy eventually depleting, as Modric and Rakitic take control of the crucial moments once again. But events have intervened. Alli and Lingard are out, and Southgate has not selected Ruben Loftus-Cheek or Fabian Delph. So England will go in with a new batch of midfielders ahead of Henderson: Harry Winks, Ross Barkley, Mason Mount and James Maddison.
Winks, remember, would surely have been part of the World Cup squad had his 2017-18 season not been ruined by ankle injury. “He’s a good connector of the game,” Southgate said when he brought Winks back into the squad. “It’s a shame that he missed a long period but he’s a technically good player who retains the ball really well. That’s an area we are trying to progress in our game.”
There is no point wondering whether England would have done better with Winks, Barkley or any other combination of midfielders at the World Cup semi-final. That game is long gone. All they can do, as they wonder whether they will ever get a chance like that again, is find a way to keep the ball better, especially under pressure, especially against the best midfielders, when the clock is ticking and every instinct is telling them to go long. It will not be easy, but where better to do it for the first time than against Modric and Rakitic tonight?
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies